The Federal High Court in Abuja on Thursday struck out a suit filed by Momoh Obaro challenging the emergence of former Kogi State Governor, Yahaya Bello, as the All Progressives Congress (APC) candidate for the 2027 Kogi Central Senatorial District election.
Delivering judgment, Justice Inyang Ekwo ruled that Obaro failed to exhaust the party’s internal dispute-resolution mechanisms before approaching the court.
The judge gave the ruling while considering preliminary objections filed by Bello and other defendants, holding that the suit was premature and should therefore be struck out.
Justice Ekwo also observed that the results of the May 18 primary election submitted by Obaro were not signed by the chairman and secretary of the committee responsible for conducting the exercise.
Speaking with journalists after the judgment, Bello’s counsel, Paul Daudu, SAN, said the court could not attach any legal evidential value to the documents presented by the plaintiff.
Daudu maintained that Obaro’s case relied on documents the court found unauthentic, describing them as a “scam”. He added that the judgment confirmed Bello’s position as the APC candidate for the senatorial election.
The News Agency of Nigeria (NAN) reports that Obaro instituted the suit, marked FHC/ABK/CS/1085/2026, through his lawyer, Kimi Appah, against the APC, Bello and the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC), listed as the first to third defendants respectively.
In the originating summons filed on May 29, Obaro asked the court to declare him the lawful winner of the May 18 APC primary, alleging that he secured the highest number of valid votes and was therefore entitled to have his name submitted to INEC as the party’s candidate.
He also sought an order restraining the APC from forwarding Bello’s name to INEC and compelling the party to recognise and submit his name as its duly nominated candidate for the 2027 senatorial election.
In an affidavit personally sworn to, Obaro alleged that Bello was neither screened nor cleared to participate in the primary election.
He claimed that he was surprised to learn that the former governor had been declared winner and his name subsequently forwarded to INEC.
In a further affidavit responding to Bello’s counter-affidavit, Obaro alleged that although Bello completed and submitted his Expression of Interest and Nomination Forms, he voluntarily withdrew from the primary election.
According to him, Bello’s withdrawal letter was submitted to the appropriate APC authorities and was never withdrawn before the primary was conducted.
However, Bello, the APC and INEC separately urged the court to dismiss the suit.
In his preliminary objection filed by Joseph Daudu, SAN, Bello argued that the case was fundamentally defective, incompetent and incapable of conferring jurisdiction on the court.
His counsel also contended that Obaro’s written address failed to comply with Paragraph 7 of the Federal High Court (Pre-Election) Practice Directions, 2026, as amended.
In his counter-affidavit, Bello dismissed Obaro’s claims, insisting that he secured the highest number of valid votes while the plaintiff finished a distant third.
He stated that Obaro polled 188 votes, while he secured 72,999 votes.
Bello further argued that Obaro failed to present the authentic and official result sheet issued by the duly constituted primary election committee.
He maintained that he was properly screened, cleared and certified as qualified to contest in the election. He also said INEC monitored the exercise before he was declared winner and his name submitted to the commission as the party’s candidate.
The former governor also denied withdrawing from the primary election.
Similarly, the APC and INEC asked the court to dismiss the suit in their separate filings.
In its counter-affidavit deposed to by Muhammad Ayuba, an administrative officer in its Litigation and Prosecution Department, INEC said it monitored the primary election in accordance with the law.
The commission stated that Bello emerged winner among the three aspirants after securing the highest number of valid votes cast during the exercise.
INEC further maintained that reports submitted by its electoral officers who monitored the primary across the various wards in the five local government areas making up Kogi Central Senatorial District showed that the exercise was substantially conducted in compliance with the Electoral Act, 2026.

