Home Politics‎Court Dismisses Atiku’s Bid to Amend Eligibility Suit Against Tinubu, APC‎

‎Court Dismisses Atiku’s Bid to Amend Eligibility Suit Against Tinubu, APC‎

by Torkuma Gbor
0 comments

The Federal High Court in Abuja on Friday dismissed an application by former Vice-President Atiku Abubakar, the African Democratic Congress (ADC) presidential candidate, seeking permission to amend his suit against President Bola Tinubu and the All Progressives Congress (APC).

‎‎Justice Inyang Ekwo, in his ruling on the motion on notice, held that the application lacked merit, agreeing with the arguments presented by Tinubu, APC and the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC) that the proposed amendments sought to introduce new facts into the case after issues had already been joined.

‎‎The judge agreed that granting the application would fundamentally alter the nature of the suit and would not serve the interest of justice.

‎‎He noted that while the plaintiffs did not initially allege fraud in their suit, their proposed amendments sought to introduce allegations of fraud. He also observed that the defendants had objected to the application on the grounds that it was intended to change the entire nature of the case.

banner

‎‎Justice Ekwo explained that pre-election matters are sui generis, meaning they belong to a special category of legal proceedings and must be treated independently. He said such cases do not permit plaintiffs to institute an action and subsequently search for evidence to support their claims.

‎‎According to him, the special nature of pre-election cases informed the Federal High Court Practice Direction, 2026.

‎‎The judge further observed that Atiku and ADC failed to challenge claims contained in the separate counter-affidavits filed by Tinubu and INEC that the application was intended to mislead the court and introduce new issues through the proposed amended originating summons.

‎‎He said the plaintiffs should have withdrawn their application after the defendants raised the objections to preserve the dignity of the court.

‎‎Justice Ekwo, however, stated that any court order obtained through fraud could be set aside at any stage of the proceedings.

‎‎“I made an order dismissing it on the grounds that the averment in Paragraph 9 of the plaintiffs is meant to mislead the court,” the judge ruled.

‎‎Having dismissed the application for lacking merit, the court adjourned the substantive matter until December 2 for hearing.

‎‎The News Agency of Nigeria (NAN) reports that Atiku and ADC had, in the main suit, asked the court to disqualify Tinubu and APC from participating in the 2027 presidential election.

‎The plaintiffs challenged the National Youth Service Corps (NYSC) discharge certificate submitted by APC to INEC on behalf of Tinubu. They alleged that the party submitted a forged certificate to the electoral commission.

‎In the suit marked FHC/ABJ/CS/1888/2026, Atiku and ADC listed Tinubu, APC and INEC as the first, second and third defendants, respectively.

‎‎They urged the court to compel INEC to remove the names of Tinubu and APC from the list of candidates and political parties for the 2027 presidential election.

‎‎Following the filing of counter-affidavits by the defendants, Atiku and ADC approached the court on September 10 with a motion on notice seeking permission to amend their originating summons, citing certain errors and irregularities in the original filing.

‎‎In the application, brought under Paragraph 7(8) of the Federal High Court (Pre-Election) Practice Directions, 2006, and the court’s inherent jurisdiction, they sought two orders: leave to amend their originating summons and an order recognising the proposed amended summons as properly filed.

‎The applicants gave four reasons for their request, stating that they instituted the suit on August 14 but subsequently discovered some errors, particularly in the description of INEC forms attached to their affidavit.

‎‎They explained that the form was identified as CF001 instead of the current Form EC9A. They also said there was a need to provide specific details of the alleged fraud in their affidavit, include a written deposition by Atiku and attach clearer copies of relevant exhibits that were unavailable when the suit was initially filed.

‎They maintained that the proposed changes would replace the documents previously attached, which they described as inelegant, without introducing any new issue or seeking additional reliefs.

‎‎The plaintiffs argued that they were entitled to amend their case in the interest of justice.

‎‎However, Tinubu opposed the application in a counter-affidavit filed on September 24 through Moses Adoga, a litigation support officer in the law firm of his lead counsel, Wole Olanipekun, SAN.

‎‎Adoga disagreed with Atiku’s arguments, stating that the proposed amended originating summons, marked Exhibit P1, sought to change the questions for determination and the reliefs originally requested.

‎‎He alleged that the plaintiffs intended to introduce an entirely new relief that was not contained in the original suit.

‎‎He also said they sought to introduce new documents by replacing Form CF001 with Form EC9 and adding fresh paragraphs to the supporting affidavit.

‎‎According to him, the proposed amendments would substantially change the entire case presented by the plaintiffs.

‎‎Adoga described the application as misconceived and disputed the claims contained in paragraphs three to 13 of the affidavit supporting the motion, alleging that they were untrue, misconceived or intended to mislead the court.

‎‎He further argued that the substantive suit was statute-barred because it was filed on August 14, although the cause of action arose on July 11, when Tinubu’s name was submitted to INEC. The commission, however, published the particulars and submitted certificates of all presidential candidates on August 1.

‎Adoga maintained that the 1999 Constitution, as amended, rather than the court’s Practice Direction, determines the timeframe for instituting such actions.

‎‎He argued that the Practice Direction could not permit a party to file or amend an originating summons after the constitutionally prescribed period had expired.

‎‎He also contended that the proposed amendment went beyond correcting errors in the description of documents, adding that the request to provide particulars of fraud amounted to an admission that the original originating summons did not contain such details.

‎‎According to him, an incompetent originating process could not be amended.

‎Adoga further maintained that the proposed amended summons contained an additional prayer and urged the court to dismiss the application in the interest of justice.

‎APC also opposed the application seeking to amend the suit.

‎‎Similarly, INEC had earlier challenged the motion in a counter-affidavit, maintaining that its preliminary objection filed on September 7 and served on the plaintiffs remained pending before the court.

‎‎Mendie Akpan, a litigation secretary in the law firm of Alex Izinyon & Co, who deposed to the commission’s counter-affidavit, argued that Atiku’s application and proposed amended summons sought to substitute or introduce a fresh cause of action.

‎‎She also stated that the applicants intended to attach a written deposition that was not filed within the constitutionally prescribed period, reformulate their reliefs and address the confusion surrounding Forms CF001 and EC9.

‎Akpan argued that granting the amendment would either introduce a new or different cause of action or attempt to correct a jurisdictional defect after the expiration of the 14-day period stipulated under Section 285(9) of the Constitution for filing pre-election cases.

You may also like

Leave a Comment